In popular culture, fathers are often portrayed as strong, sensitive, and stoic figures—a representation so pervasive that it appears across everything from celebrity endorsements to joke books and even hard seltzers. However, real life offers a different narrative. Fathers, too, experience emotional struggles, including depression, which can have lasting effects on their children.
A recent study from Rutgers Health sheds light on the often overlooked issue of paternal depression and its consequences. Published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, the study reveals the significant social and behavioral impacts on children when paternal depression goes undiagnosed or untreated.
The study, led by Kristine Schmitz, an assistant professor of pediatrics at Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, along with collaborators from RWJMS, Princeton, and Rider universities, found that children exposed to paternal depression as they entered kindergarten were much more likely to experience behavioral challenges and poor social skills by age 9.
“Depression in fathers deserves more attention. It’s not just mothers who need support—fathers do too. Depression is treatable, and pediatricians should start addressing it with fathers, developing interventions that specifically meet their needs,” said Schmitz.
The study highlights that between 8% and 13% of fathers in the U.S. experience some form of depression during their child’s early years. This figure jumps to 50% when the mother is also dealing with postpartum depression. However, few studies have explored the long-term impact of paternal depression, particularly beyond the postnatal period, or investigated its link to children’s behavior.
To fill this research gap, Schmitz and her team analyzed data from the Future of Families and Child Wellbeing Study (FFCWS), a national cohort that tracked births in 20 major U.S. cities between 1998 and 2000. The study continues to follow participants’ lives, providing valuable insights into family dynamics over time.
The researchers focused on two key points of data: when the children were 5 years old, their fathers were screened for depressive symptoms, and when the children were 9, their teachers provided behavioral assessments. These findings underscored the importance of addressing mental health at critical developmental stages.
“Kindergarten entry is a significant milestone. Challenges at this stage can affect a child’s behavior and engagement in school, with these issues potentially persisting throughout their academic journey,” Schmitz explained.
The study compared data from 1,422 fathers, 74% of whom lived with their children at least half of the time when the child was 5, and looked at the correlation between paternal depression and the children’s behavior. After controlling for sociodemographic factors and maternal depression, a clear link emerged: children whose fathers reported depressive symptoms at age 5 were more likely to exhibit restlessness, defiance, anger, and lower levels of cooperation and self-esteem by age 9.
The study suggests that paternal depression can impact parenting, leading to reduced emotional support and increased conflict within the home—factors that contribute to children’s behavioral difficulties.
Schmitz emphasized that this study is the first of its kind to establish such a definitive link between paternal depression and child behavior, calling for a greater focus on interventions aimed at supporting fathers struggling with their mental health.
While the study underscores the challenges associated with paternal depression, there is also reason for optimism. Schmitz believes that early identification and intervention can improve both fathers’ and children’s well-being. “By addressing mental health, we not only support fathers but also teach children a valuable lesson about seeking help when needed—a lesson they will carry with them for life,” she said.
In conclusion, this groundbreaking research advocates for a more holistic approach to family mental health, urging both healthcare providers and society to recognize the crucial role fathers play in shaping their children’s future.
Related topics:
Nature-Based Activities Show Positive Mental Health Benefits in New Study
Physical Activity May Slow Brain Aging and Cognitive Decline
Toxic Chemicals Found in Children’s Sleep Environments
