A recent study published in the British Journal of Nutrition explored the impact of traditional versus modified dietary patterns on hypertension among Japanese workers. The findings suggest that a modified Japanese diet, rich in whole grains, dairy, raw vegetables, and fruits, may be inversely associated with hypertension, while the traditional Japanese diet showed no significant link to the condition.
Study Overview
The research, conducted on 12,213 Japanese workers, aimed to assess how adherence to either a traditional or modified Japanese diet influenced hypertension prevalence. Hypertension, which affects approximately 1.28 billion adults globally, is a key contributor to stroke and heart disease. It is well-documented that diet, particularly sodium consumption, plays a crucial role in managing blood pressure.
The study utilized data from the Japan Epidemiology Collaboration on Occupational Health (J-ECOH) study, which ran from 2018 to 2020. The participants, predominantly male (88.1%), completed lifestyle questionnaires and health checkups. Blood pressure was measured during these checkups, and hypertension was diagnosed based on systolic pressure above 140 mmHg, diastolic pressure above 90 mmHg, or use of antihypertensive medication.
Dietary Patterns and Health Implications
The researchers compared two dietary patterns: the traditional Japanese diet, which includes green tea, fish, soy products, miso soup, seaweed, and white rice, and the modified diet, which substitutes whole grains for white rice and adds raw vegetables, fruits, and dairy. While salty foods like pickles and soy sauce were penalized in the modified diet score, fermented soy products like natto and miso soup were rewarded.
Previous studies have linked the traditional Japanese diet, high in sodium, to increased blood pressure, despite its other health benefits. However, sodium intake in Japan has declined since World War II, and modern diets now include more fruits, dairy, and other Western foods. This shift has prompted health authorities to recommend increased consumption of vegetables and fruits and a reduction in salt intake to manage hypertension.
Key Findings
Initial analyses showed that higher adherence to both the traditional and modified diets was linked to lower rates of hypertension. However, after accounting for confounding variables, only the modified diet showed a suggestive inverse association with hypertension. Notably, workers with fewer than 13 years of education exhibited stronger benefits from the modified diet. In contrast, among those with a lower body mass index (BMI < 23 kg/m²), the traditional diet was positively associated with hypertension.
Potential Implications for Public Health
The study suggests that the modified Japanese diet, emphasizing potassium- and fiber-rich foods with reduced sodium content, may be more effective in controlling blood pressure. It is believed that the increased intake of these nutrient-dense foods may help counteract the blood pressure-raising effects of sodium by enhancing sodium excretion and improving nutrient balance.
However, the traditional Japanese diet, despite containing foods like vegetables and seaweed that are typically associated with blood pressure-lowering effects, did not show a clear link to reduced hypertension. The balance between beneficial and harmful foods, along with the relatively younger age of the study participants (mean age 42), may have weakened the observed effect.
Study Limitations
The study’s cross-sectional design means that causality cannot be definitively established. Additionally, the reliance on self-reported dietary data and the possibility of unmeasured confounding variables may limit the accuracy of the findings. The sample, which was predominantly male and employed at large companies, may not be representative of the broader Japanese population.
Conclusion
While this study suggests that adopting a modernized Japanese diet could help prevent hypertension, further longitudinal studies are needed to confirm these findings. The research underscores the importance of dietary patterns in managing blood pressure while highlighting the potential benefits of retaining cultural food practices with a more health-conscious approach to nutrition.
Related topics:
Vitamin K Deficiency Linked to Cognitive Decline in Aging
Mediterranean Diet and Exercise Combat Bone Loss in Older Women
Fiber-Rich Diet Shown to Combat Intestinal Infections
